HANDYMAN & HOME REPAIR · 2026 GUIDE
10 Best Handyman Companies on Long Island
A sticking door, damaged drywall, and a loose railing rarely need the same specialist as a full renovation. These ten Long Island handyman businesses publish repair or improvement services. Blue Whale Handyman is our #1 editorial pick. Every company has earned its place; use the comparisons to find the right scope and service area for your home. No position is paid for.
How to use this guide
- Blue Whale Handyman is our first pick for a varied repair list with a Huntington-based crew.
- Match the task list and your exact town to the provider; a small repair and a remodeling project need different scopes.
- Compare the total visit cost, materials, cleanup, and change approvals rather than labour rates alone.
The shortlist at a glance
Compare the job you need done, the stated coverage, and the kind of customer evidence available.
| Rank | Company | Useful fit | Stated coverage | Specialism | Review evidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Blue Whale HandymanTOP PICKWebsite | A bundled repair list with an owner-led local crew | Huntington; Nassau & Suffolk | Huntington-based crew | HomeAdvisor: 4.9/5 · 25 reviewsThird-party reviews |
| 02 | Mr. Handyman of Nassau CountyWebsite | Nassau repairs through a locally operated franchise | Nassau County; confirm your town | Home and business repairs | Trustindex: 4.7/5 · 271 reviewsThird-party reviews |
| 03 | JamHandy, LLCWebsite | Home repairs combined with exterior cleaning | Melville, Northport & nearby; Nassau/Suffolk | Repairs and power washing | Company testimonials only confirmedCompany-published feedback |
| 04 | P & K Handyman Services LLCWebsite | Levittown-area repair and maintenance projects | Levittown & surrounding areas | Residential and commercial projects | HomeAdvisor: 5.0/5 · 6 reviewsThird-party reviews |
| 05 | L.I. N.Y. Handyman ServiceWebsite | Repairs involving leaks, water damage, kitchens, or bathrooms | Bethpage, Hicksville, Plainview & nearby | Repairs and water damage | Independent reviews not confirmedLimited review evidence |
| 06 | Josh is HandyWebsite | Repairs that overlap with clean-outs, moving help, or yard work | Primarily Suffolk County & nearby towns | Handyman and clean-out services | Company-published review claimsCompany-published feedback |
| 07 | ProfixterWebsite | Recurring home maintenance rather than only a one-off repair | Long Island; address coverage to confirm | One-time visits and memberships | Independent customer reviews not confirmedLimited review evidence |
| 08 | Helping HandsWebsite | Assembly, painting, patio restoration, and household odd jobs | Syosset-based; Long Island | Residential handywork and assembly | Independent reviews not confirmedLimited review evidence |
| 09 | Long Island HandymanWebsite | Repair work that may extend into tile or remodeling | Islip-area listing; Nassau & Suffolk projects | Islip-area home improvements | Review identity not confirmedLimited review evidence |
| 10 | HandyHands / Long Island Handyman ServicesWebsite | A further local quote after confirming the exact service scope | Long Island; town coverage to confirm | Local handyman services | Independent reviews not confirmedLimited review evidence |
Platform ratings are source snapshots, not our own scores. Totals can change or lag the live platform, and records may cover a branch or a wider region. Company testimonials are labeled separately; an unconfirmed review record does not mean poor service.
Huntington-based crew
Blue Whale Handyman
Blue Whale Handyman publishes home repairs, carpentry, painting, deck work, and remodeling services. Its Huntington base serves Nassau and Suffolk areas, subject to the project address. It is worth discussing a bundled repair list with the crew and requesting an itemized estimate.
- Best suited for
- A bundled repair list with an owner-led local crew
- Stated service area
- Huntington; Nassau & Suffolk
Why it ranks here
Our first pick for a varied household repair list: broad repair and renovation services, a Huntington base, and positive third-party feedback about workmanship, communication, and care for the property.
Standout strengths
- Published carpentry, drywall, painting, deck, and remodeling services suit a repair list that spans several tasks.
- The Huntington base and Nassau/Suffolk coverage provide a local starting point for coordinating household work.
The practical trade-off
Bundling tasks is useful only when the scope is clear. Separate small repairs from renovation work, identify materials, and agree how newly discovered damage will be quoted.
Third-party reviews
HomeAdvisor: 4.9/5 · 25 reviews
HomeAdvisor displays 4.9 from 25 reviews. Visible feedback includes a May 2026 installation review and recurring praise for communication, dependable attendance, workmanship, and cleanup.
Blue Whale Handyman on HomeAdvisorSource snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Confirm availability, estimate charges, and who performs specialized work. Ask for an itemized scope when combining small repairs with renovation tasks.
Ask Blue Whale Handyman
Can you itemize my repair list, identify which tasks can be completed together, and explain materials, cleanup, specialized-trade work, and approval of any added costs?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Home and business repairs
Mr. Handyman of Nassau County
This locally operated franchise publishes repair and installation services for Nassau County. Ask whether your tasks fit its booking minimum and which technician or licensed trade will perform the work.
- Best suited for
- Nassau repairs through a locally operated franchise
- Stated service area
- Nassau County; confirm your town
Why it ranks here
Its established local franchise offering and comparatively large public-review footprint make it a strong second comparison for routine repairs and installations, especially for Nassau homeowners.
Standout strengths
- The locally operated franchise publishes home and business repair and installation services.
- A comparatively large local review record lets readers examine both recent praise and concerns.
The practical trade-off
A booking minimum or labour structure can change the value of a short visit. Compare the full visit cost for your task list rather than an hourly figure alone.
Third-party reviews
Trustindex: 4.7/5 · 271 reviews
The opened Trustindex snapshot displays 271 Google reviews at 4.7, with both positive and low ratings. Visible positive comments mention professional, prompt, neat service. Other indexed snapshots show a newer count.
Nassau County reviews on TrustindexSource snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Ask about booking minimums, labour rates, materials, and the technician assigned. Review recent low-rated feedback as well as positive experiences.
Ask Mr. Handyman of Nassau County
What is the minimum charge for my Nassau address, which materials or travel costs are additional, and how is extra time approved if the repair takes longer?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Repairs and power washing
JamHandy, LLC
JamHandy lists Long Island handyman services and describes its Melville and Northport base. Its site also advertises power washing. Confirm availability for your specific repair list and request the scope in writing.
- Best suited for
- Home repairs combined with exterior cleaning
- Stated service area
- Melville, Northport & nearby; Nassau/Suffolk
Why it ranks here
A clear combination of handyman work and power washing, with named local service areas. That practical combination earns its place for households coordinating repairs and exterior maintenance.
Standout strengths
- Handyman work and power washing can address both repair and exterior-maintenance needs.
- Named Melville and Northport coverage gives nearby homeowners a clear place to begin checking service availability.
The practical trade-off
Cleaning and repair work need separate scopes even when booked together. Confirm the surface, cleaning method, repair sequence, and any protection needed around landscaping or finishes.
Company-published feedback
Company testimonials only confirmed
The company’s selected testimonials praise punctuality, responsiveness, and completed work. They are hosted by the business; our review did not confirm a separate attributable platform tally.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Ask for recent references for work like yours. Confirm whether a surface needs pressure washing or a gentler method before agreeing to the scope.
Ask JamHandy, LLC
For my repair and exterior-cleaning list, which tasks should happen first, what cleaning method suits each surface, and are repairs and washing priced separately?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Residential and commercial projects
P & K Handyman Services LLC
P & K lists carpentry, painting, pressure washing, and other repair services. Its website identifies Levittown and surrounding areas. Verify the current coverage and any trade requirements for your project.
- Best suited for
- Levittown-area repair and maintenance projects
- Stated service area
- Levittown & surrounding areas
Why it ranks here
Its local coverage, varied repair offering, and positive platform feedback make it a useful nearby comparison. The small, older review sample limits how confidently it describes current performance.
Standout strengths
- The published mix of carpentry, painting, pressure washing, and repairs suits varied maintenance jobs.
- Levittown and surrounding coverage makes it a practical nearby quote for homeowners in that area.
The practical trade-off
The cited customer-review sample is small and older. Use recent references and a detailed current estimate to assess the work you need today.
Third-party reviews
HomeAdvisor: 5.0/5 · 6 reviews
HomeAdvisor displays six reviews at 5.0. Comments praise professionalism and repeat service; one customer raises price as a concern. The visible dates are January–April 2022.
P & K Handyman on HomeAdvisorSource snapshot examined .
Before you hire
The visible reviews are from 2022. Ask for recent references, current insurance, and a written price for the full repair list.
Ask P & K Handyman Services LLC
Can you provide a recent example of a repair like mine and a written quote showing labour, materials, surface preparation, and any minimum visit charge?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Repairs and water damage
L.I. N.Y. Handyman Service
This business publishes carpentry, plumbing repair, kitchens, bathrooms, and water-damage work. Its site names Bethpage, Hicksville, Plainview, and surrounding communities. Ask how it diagnoses the source of a problem before repairing finishes.
- Best suited for
- Repairs involving leaks, water damage, kitchens, or bathrooms
- Stated service area
- Bethpage, Hicksville, Plainview & nearby
Why it ranks here
Its published leak-finding and water-damage work gives it a distinct role in the shortlist, beyond assembly and cosmetic repairs. Review confidence remains limited.
Standout strengths
- Published water-damage and leak-related services distinguish it from an assembly-only repair option.
- Kitchen, bathroom, and carpentry work may be relevant when a repair affects several parts of a room.
The practical trade-off
Repairing a visible stain or damaged finish is different from resolving the source of moisture. Establish what will be investigated and when a separate specialist is needed.
Limited review evidence
Independent reviews not confirmed
The website identifies Chris Moore and named local coverage. Its review link leads to a broad Google search, so we did not treat it as a verified business-specific review record.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Ask how the source of water damage will be diagnosed and which work needs a licensed specialist. Get repair boundaries and follow-up responsibilities in writing.
Ask L.I. N.Y. Handyman Service
How will you determine the source of the water damage before repairing finishes, which tasks require another trade, and what follow-up is included if the issue returns?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Handyman and clean-out services
Josh is Handy
Josh is Handy publishes handyman and clean-out work serving Long Island, primarily Suffolk County. It is an option to consider when repairs overlap with clearing or moving items. Confirm the tasks and disposal charges before booking.
- Best suited for
- Repairs that overlap with clean-outs, moving help, or yard work
- Stated service area
- Primarily Suffolk County & nearby towns
Why it ranks here
The combined repair, clean-out, and practical household-help offering makes it useful when a job crosses several tasks. Inclusion is supported by service fit rather than a confirmed independent review score.
Standout strengths
- Published clean-out and household-help services offer a useful combination when access must be cleared before repairs.
- A primarily Suffolk focus provides another option for a mixed household task list.
The practical trade-off
Hauling and disposal can change a mixed-job quote. Describe what needs moving or removing and separate those charges from the repair labour.
Company-published feedback
Company-published review claims
The site advertises five-star local feedback. Our research did not establish a separate attributable platform record, so that claim is not presented here as an independently confirmed star rating.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Confirm hauling, disposal, labour, and material charges separately. Ask for a recent reference for the main task you need done.
Ask Josh is Handy
Can you quote the repair work, lifting or moving help, and disposal separately, including any items you cannot take and any additional charges?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
One-time visits and memberships
Profixter
Profixter publishes handyman memberships, one-time visits, and larger projects for Long Island homes. Compare a membership with a single visit based on the work you actually need and review cancellation terms.
- Best suited for
- Recurring home maintenance rather than only a one-off repair
- Stated service area
- Long Island; address coverage to confirm
Why it ranks here
The membership model distinguishes it from conventional one-visit handyman bookings. It earns a comparison spot for readers evaluating ongoing maintenance, with limited independent customer evidence.
Standout strengths
- The membership offering gives homeowners an alternative to arranging every maintenance visit individually.
- Published one-time visits and larger projects allow a comparison between recurring and occasional service.
The practical trade-off
A membership works best when its included time and tasks match your actual needs. Compare usage, exclusions, scheduling, and cancellation terms with the likely cost of individual visits.
Limited review evidence
Independent customer reviews not confirmed
The source review confirmed the maintenance membership and one-time service offering. Website safety-check listings were excluded because they do not establish workmanship or customer satisfaction.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Compare included hours, excluded work, cancellation rules, and response times against a one-time visit. Automated website safety scores are not customer reviews.
Ask Profixter
What time and tasks are included in the membership, does unused time carry over, how are larger jobs priced, and what happens when I cancel?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Residential handywork and assembly
Helping Hands
Helping Hands describes residential handywork on Long Island. Ask about the exact assembly or repair tasks, travel coverage, and whether materials are included in the estimate.
- Best suited for
- Assembly, painting, patio restoration, and household odd jobs
- Stated service area
- Syosset-based; Long Island
Why it ranks here
A clearly identified Syosset business with an assembly and small-project focus. It is a useful fit for defined household jobs; independent customer sentiment was not established in this review.
Standout strengths
- Published assembly and household odd-job services suit a clearly defined small-project brief.
- Painting and patio-restoration work broaden the comparison beyond furniture assembly alone.
The practical trade-off
A small job can still need preparation, materials, or disposal that is not obvious from a task name. Send photos and model details before treating an initial estimate as complete.
Limited review evidence
Independent reviews not confirmed
The company website identifies Trakas LLC, DBA Helping Hands. We did not attach reviews from similarly named businesses or treat a founder’s self-published rating claims as a platform record.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Specify the task, materials, access, and disposal requirements. Ask for recent references and confirm coverage before relying on its advertised estimate turnaround.
Ask Helping Hands
For this assembly or restoration job, are preparation, materials, packaging removal, and protection of nearby surfaces included, and do you cover my town?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Islip-area home improvements
Long Island Handyman
This Islip business publishes repair and improvement services including decking, flooring, painting, and remodeling. Confirm its current service area and whether specialized work requires a separately licensed contractor.
- Best suited for
- Repair work that may extend into tile or remodeling
- Stated service area
- Islip-area listing; Nassau & Suffolk projects
Why it ranks here
Its broad improvement and renovation offering provides another option when repairs may grow into a larger project. The generic business name makes careful identity matching important.
Standout strengths
- Published decking, flooring, painting, and remodeling services suit repairs with a possible larger improvement scope.
- The Islip-area business provides another option to compare for work beyond isolated household fixes.
The practical trade-off
A repair that grows into remodeling needs a new scope, schedule, and approval process. Confirm the exact business identity as well as how larger changes will be handled.
Limited review evidence
Review identity not confirmed
We confirmed published services but did not confidently match an independent review profile to this website. Reviews for a similarly named West Islip provider were excluded.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Confirm the business behind handymanlongisland.com and phone 631-383-6052 on your estimate. Do not assume another “Long Island Handyman” review profile refers to this company.
Ask Long Island Handyman
If the repair reveals a larger flooring, deck, or remodeling issue, how will you document it, price the change, and confirm which business and crew will perform the work?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
Local handyman services
HandyHands / Long Island Handyman Services
The Long Island Handyman Services website identifies HandyHands and offers service requests. Ask for a current service list, the business identity on your estimate, and written confirmation that your address is covered.
- Best suited for
- A further local quote after confirming the exact service scope
- Stated service area
- Long Island; town coverage to confirm
Why it ranks here
Included as an additional local service-request option. Its website provides less detailed service and review evidence than the earlier profiles, so the pre-booking conversation carries more importance.
Standout strengths
- The published service-request route gives readers an additional Long Island quote option.
- The site identifies HandyHands and Long Island Handyman Services, which readers can use when confirming the provider.
The practical trade-off
The available website detail is thinner than several other options. A written service list and provider information are especially useful before scheduling a visit.
Limited review evidence
Independent reviews not confirmed
The website identifies Long Island Handyman Services and HandyHands. We found no independently attributable review record in the sources examined; no customer rating is assigned.
Source snapshot examined .
Before you hire
Request a current service list and the legal business name on the estimate. Verify credentials directly rather than relying on a displayed license number.
Ask HandyHands / Long Island Handyman Services
What is your current service list, which business name appears on the estimate, do you cover my address, and can you provide current insurance and relevant references?
Service information: Company website · reviewed . Published claims and credentials should be confirmed directly.
A BETTER FIRST CONVERSATION
Make your repair list easy to quote
Give every provider the same photos and task list. That makes it easier to identify missing work and compare a single visit with a larger project or maintenance membership.
- Your town, photos, measurements where available, and a numbered list of the repairs.
- Materials or fixtures you already have, assembly model numbers, access constraints, and the desired timing.
- A request to separate labour, supplied materials, minimum charges, travel, and disposal.
- Written confirmation of cleanup, specialist-trade responsibilities, and approval of added work.
MAKE A MORE INFORMED CHOICE
Before you book.
- Send photos and one complete task list before requesting an estimate.
- Verify insurance and any licenses required for the work in your jurisdiction.
- Ask about minimum booking time, materials, and cleanup.
- Keep the agreed scope, price, and change process in writing.
Common questions
How do I choose a handyman on Long Island?
Match the tasks to the business’s stated services, confirm coverage at your address, and request a written estimate. Check current insurance and any licensing required for the work.
Can I combine several small repairs into one visit?
Often, but confirm with the business. Share the full list and photos so it can plan time, tools, and materials before arriving.
Does a handyman handle every electrical or plumbing job?
No. Requirements and capabilities depend on the task and location. Ask who will perform specialized work and verify the relevant license before proceeding.
How we compared these companies
We examined official service information and searched for public feedback attributable to each business. We distinguish third-party review platforms, company-selected testimonials, and records we could not confidently match. Each ranking rationale explains the service fit; none is a guarantee that the business will outperform every alternative.
Where available, platform ratings and counts come from the source snapshots reviewed, including indexed pages when a full page was unavailable. These can lag live totals. We do not add platform counts together, infer a rating when none is established, or apply one branch’s reviews to every location. A positive regional or general-service review is not automatically evidence for the exact service at your address.
Read the complete editorial policy